Best of Awards: what organizers' rules say about business votes
In short Two Best of awards examined here forbid a business to pay voters for picks: The Pitch's Best of KC prohibits it, and the Santa Barbara Independent disqualifies a business that offers voters any kind of incentive in Best of Santa Barbara once it discovers it. Pittsburgh Magazine can remove a finalist for flagrant stuffing of the count, and none of the three contest rules is worded as a ban on buying votes by name.
Published · Rules last checked · Voting Now
Voting Now runs advertising channels that reach real people and bring votes, and those channels do not break the organizer's rules. Before a launch, we compare them with the rules for that specific contest. Buy contest votes
The Pitch, the Santa Barbara Independent and Pittsburgh Magazine each state a consequence
The table keeps each rule with the organizer that states it, so the wording of one organizer is not read into the rules of another. Two of the rules are aimed at what a business offers voters, and the third is aimed at the count itself.
| Organizer and award | Conduct the rules name | What the rules say follows |
|---|---|---|
| The Pitch, Best of KC | Offering voters payment or another incentive for a pick | Strictly prohibited, and disqualification may follow |
| Santa Barbara Independent, Best of Santa Barbara | Any kind of incentive offered to voters | The business is disqualified once the Independent discovers it |
| Pittsburgh Magazine, Best of the 'Burgh readers poll | Flagrant evidence of stuffing the count | The magazine may take a business off its list of finalists |
The Pitch sets a per-entrant limit inside a program of more than 500 categories
The Pitch's rules page is described as allowing “one valid entry per entrant per day in nominations and one per round in final voting”. The paper's Best of KC spans more than 500 categories, a scope the paper says is meant to capture all of Kansas City.
In 2026, the nomination stage of Best of KC closed on March 31, 2026, and the finalist reveal that leads into the final round was dated April 22, 2026. Readers nominate first and then pick among finalists, so the per-entrant limit applies at each of those two stages.
At Best of Santa Barbara a form covering fewer than 20 categories has none of its choices counted
For Best of Santa Barbara 2026, the form of the Santa Barbara Independent is described as requiring readers to “nominate and vote in at least 20 categories, or none of their choices count”. Readers who want to buy contest votes should first read which votes the contest rules count.
Pittsburgh Magazine draws no line from its advertisers to the winners of Best of the 'Burgh
Pittsburgh Magazine's own account of how its poll works says there is zero connection between its advertisers and its winners, and the FAQ of Rhode Island Monthly states that advertising with the magazine is not a condition of a Best of Rhode Island win. According to the FAQ of The Pitch, an advertiser may remind readers of its work before the final round and gets no special treatment when the votes are counted.
The organizer's own rules settle the main questions before any request for votes goes out
A guide to winning a Best of or Readers' Choice award for a local business covers the three stages these rules sit inside, which are nominations, the finalist cut and the public vote. Each of the three organizers states its rule in its own words and for its own edition.
- Find the sentence on incentives in the rules of the edition you enter, since The Pitch and the Santa Barbara Independent both state one.
- Find the line on stuffing and removal that Pittsburgh Magazine states for finalists in its Best of the 'Burgh readers poll.
- Read how many entries per person each stage counts, because the limits differ from one award to the next.
- Offer nothing for a pick when you ask customers to nominate or vote, because The Pitch prohibits paying voters or giving them any other incentive for a pick.
- Put any doubt about a rule to the organizer in writing and keep the reply.
Questions and answers
Can an entry be disqualified for bought votes?
None of the three contest rules names bought votes in so many words. The Pitch says disqualification may follow an incentive offered for a pick, the Santa Barbara Independent disqualifies a business once it discovers an incentive, and Pittsburgh Magazine reserves a right to remove a finalist.
Can a business ask customers to nominate it in Best of KC?
Yes, the FAQ of The Pitch invites a business to ask its followers, customers, family and friends for nominations. The same FAQ allows anyone in Kansas City to submit one nomination per category. The ban on paying voters or giving them any other incentive for a pick sits beside that encouragement.
Does Pittsburgh Magazine explain what flagrant means in its removal rule?
The line Pittsburgh Magazine publishes on removing a finalist gives no definition of the word flagrant. The magazine may take a business off the list of finalists when the evidence of stuffing the count is flagrant. A business that needs a definition has to ask the magazine, because the line itself gives none.
Does a business have to be nominated before it can win?
In The Pitch's Best of KC, readers nominate first and then pick among finalists, so a nomination comes before the final round. At Best of Santa Barbara the voting round is multiple choice and is built from the list that readers crafted during nominations, which leaves a business nobody nominated off that list.
For a Best of award, the organizer's rules for the edition you enter are the page to read before you ask a single customer for a pick, and a dated copy of them is worth saving.