Voting Now
Voting Now
Send a link

Joining a vote exchange group: what organizers' rules say

In short Whether joining a vote exchange group is against the rules depends on the wording of each contest's own rules. County Lines Magazine warns that a Cutest Pet entry may be disqualified when voting exchanges are used during its Facebook voting, while the Arizona Daily Star words its Readers' Choice limit around each user. Where the rules are silent on swaps, the organizer picks the reading that applies, so check the contest's rules before joining a group.

Published · Rules last checked · Voting Now

Voting Now runs advertising channels that reach real people and bring votes, and those channels do not break the organizer's rules. Before a launch, we compare them with the rules for that specific contest. Buy contest votes

The Cutest Pet rules of County Lines Magazine call out voting exchanges by name

According to the rules of County Lines Magazine, “voting exchanges or similar systems used during its Facebook voting period may lead to disqualification”. Part of the magazine's Cutest Pet contest takes place on Facebook, and the warning is about an entry in that contest.

Other organizers state daily limits and removal powers that bear on a swap

The table sets out how other organizers word their daily limits and their powers of removal, and whether each wording speaks to groups at all.

Wording of other organizers' rules that bears on a swap or on removal, by organizer and contest
Organizer and contestWhat the rules stateWording on groups or removal
Arizona Daily Star, Readers' ChoiceA single vote per user each 24 hours; midnight does not restart that clockNot addressed by that wording
Peninsula Daily News, county fair photo contestDaily choice; deadline 11:59 a.m., September 4, 2014Silent on groups
Brevard Humane SocietyIts contest integrity rulesVotes that break them may be stripped
Oregon HumaneAn entry under suspicion of tamperingThe entry may be disqualified

Central Florida Lifestyle's Cutest Pet rules allow a winner to be disqualified

Under Central Florida Lifestyle's Cutest Pet contest rules, the organizer “reserves the right to disqualify a winner” for activity capable of manipulating the public tally. That right is about a winner, whereas Brevard Humane Society, in the table above, “may strip votes that break its contest integrity rules”.

When a rule says nothing about swaps, the organizer chooses between two readings

A limit phrased around each user does not forbid picking a stranger's entry, and it does not approve a trade arranged inside a group. Silence on swaps leaves room for two readings, and it is the organizer who selects the one that governs an entry.

The first reading takes each member for a genuine person with a genuine daily choice. The second reading sees a choice that was handed over in return for something. Once the organizer applies the second reading to an entry, the entrant cannot argue for the first reading.

These checks in the rules come before joining any group

For swaps themselves, see the guide to vote exchange groups; the list below stays with what a contest's own rules say.

  • Write down the line of the contest's rules that says how often a person may pick, since a swap would have to fit within that line.
  • Scan the rules for clauses on fraud, coordinated picks, incentives or anything promised to someone in exchange for a pick, because a clause like that already settles the swap question for that contest.
  • Check the rules for any wording on outside assistance, exchanges or conduct that could distort the count.
  • Work out who decides the result, whether that is a straight public count, finalists chosen by judges first, or a likes round that ends with a panel.
  • Put one question to the organizer in writing, asking whether a pick given in return for another pick is counted, and save the reply.
  • If the organizer says no, or does not reply, step out of the group for that entry and let the members who are owed a pick know, so that nobody expects one back.

Questions and answers

What is a vote exchange group?

A vote exchange group lets entrants from different online contests trade picks one for one, and it takes the form of a chat, a forum thread or a social group. Vote trading and vote swapping are other labels for that arrangement, and a favor, for instance a shared post, can stand in for the returned choice.

Does text voting change what a user can choose in the Arizona Daily Star's Readers' Choice?

Yes, in the Arizona Daily Star's Readers' Choice a text vote brings one further choice per day, delivered as a code to a number that the paper publishes. A swap enlarges neither that allowance nor the ordinary one, because a swap only hands the pick to another entrant's entry. A text pick traded for another pick is a traded pick like any other.

What should you assume when the rules do not mention groups?

A rule that names no groups leaves the question open until the organizer answers in writing, so plan as if the answer were no. Once the organizer says yes in writing, the question of whether a traded pick counts is settled, and that written answer carries more weight than anything a group admin says. If the organizer answers no, the group is ruled out for that entry.

Whose Facebook post must a supporter like to help a Cutest Pet entry?

A supporter has to like the magazine's original post, since likes on copies are not counted. The magazine tallies likes on its original posts, and a panel of judges then reviews the photos in the lead. In the third round, that panel examines the photos whose original posts drew the largest number of likes.

In any public-vote contest the organizer's published rules decide, so read the per-person limit and the removal clause before a group asks you for a pick.

Voting Now is a contest marketing agency that runs advertising for entries in public-vote contests and polls.