Best of the Bay: a tie during nominations moves both nominees
In short In Best of the Bay 2026, the organizer's rule is that a tie in nominations sends both tied nominees to the voting round. That rule stands in the organizer's own announcement for the 2026 edition. Open nominations were extended to 11:59 p.m. on June 14, 2026; the voting round closed on August 30, 2026.
Published · Rules last checked · Voting Now
Voting Now runs advertising channels that reach real people and bring votes, and those channels do not break the organizer's rules. Before a launch, we compare them with the rules for that specific contest. Buy contest votes
The organizer's tie rule sends both tied nominees to the voting round
For the 2026 edition, the organizer's Best of the Bay announcement answers the tie question in one clause. It reads: “If there is a tie during nominations, both nominees will move to the voting round.” That rule sits in a passage about the public nomination phase, which the same announcement describes as a month-long stretch that accepted thousands of nominations.
The announcement keeps the nomination and the vote apart as two phases, with the leading nominees moving on to the vote. The tie rule tells you what happens at the cut line: a tie does not remove one of the two nominees, because both go forward together.
2026 nominations ran from May 14, 2026, through June 10, 2026, with an extension to June 14, 2026
The organizer's announcement holds open nominations from May 14th, 2026 through June 10, 2026. Creative Loafing Tampa pushed the nomination deadline for the 2026 Best of the Bay back to 11:59 p.m. on Sunday, June 14, 2026, giving readers extra days to nominate.
The stages below gather the 2026 dates the organizer's announcement and Creative Loafing Tampa's own notices state, so you can place the tie rule at the end of the nomination phase.
| Stage | 2026 dates | What the text adds |
|---|---|---|
| Open nominations | May 14, 2026, through June 10, 2026, extended to 11:59 p.m. on June 14, 2026 | The public submits the nominations; a tie sends both nominees forward |
| Voting round | July 23, 2026, through August 30, 2026 | The nominee with the most votes in a category takes the 2026 title |
| Party | Wednesday, October 7, 2026, at the Coliseum, St. Petersburg, FL | An event restricted to adults; finalists were to be contacted with a discount code. |
| Best of the Bay issue | October 8, 2026, on stands and online | The winners were announced in the annual issue |
Readers' Picks and Critics' Picks split the Best of the Bay awards
The organizer's announcement states: “Best of the Bay is split up into two sets of awards: Readers' Picks and Critics' Picks.” The Readers' Picks are the awards the public submits and votes on, and the tie rule above belongs to that public track.
Creative Loafing does not decide the winners and finalists of the Readers' Picks, and the site's coverage of the contest records the same point. The Critics' Pick Awards are curated by Creative Loafing staff, and the organizer accepts no nominations for them. A nomination tie could therefore arise only where the public nominates, which the announcement places on the Readers' Picks side.
The 2026 voting round closed on August 30, 2026
The organizer's announcement reads: “The top nominees in each category move to the voting round on July 23rd, 2026 through August 30th, 2026.” The 2026 final round opened to readers on July 23, 2026, and ran until the 11:59 p.m. close on Sunday, August 30, 2026, with nine categories on the ballot, among them Arts, Food, Goods and Places.
For the result, the announcement says: “The nominee with the most votes in that specific category during the voting around will walk away with the title for 2026.” Creative Loafing holds that count itself; nothing in the announcement or in the site's contest coverage gives readers or outside parties a hand in it.
What a 2026 nominee could check once nominations closed
A nominee who wondered whether the nomination phase had carried them through had a few concrete things to look at in the organizer's announcement.
- Register the business or person on the ballot, because the announcement asks nominees to register so the organizer can notify them about reaching the voting round.
- Use the public form the organizer provided, where the top 15 nominees could submit contact info to keep the contact on file up to date.
- Check the spam folder, since the announcement tells nominees directly to check it for the finalist message.
- Look for the finalist discount code for the party, which the announcement says finalists in each category will be contacted with.
- Watch for the Best of the Bay issue, which carried the full list of winners.
Questions and answers
What happens if there is a tie during the Best of the Bay voting round itself?
The organizer's announcement states a tie rule for nominations only: both tied nominees move to the voting round. For the voting round, the text gives only the outcome rule, that the nominee with the most votes in a category takes the 2026 title, and it names no tie case for that count.
How were the nominees narrowed down for the 2026 voting round?
The voting round took the top 15 nominees in each category, and the organizers asked those 15 to submit their contact info through a public form. Creative Loafing Tampa's announcement left open how those 15 were ranked, and the organizer's text states one case at that cut: a tie in nominations carried both nominees into the vote.
Are the Readers' Picks of Best of the Bay 2026 staff-curated?
No. Creative Loafing does not decide the winners and finalists of the Readers' Picks, which are submitted and voted on by the public, so that track sits outside the staff's control. The Critics' Pick Awards are the exception: Creative Loafing staff curates them and accepts no nominations for those.
When could readers nominate for the 2026 Best of the Bay?
Open nominations ran from May 14, 2026, through June 10, 2026, according to the organizer's announcement. The same text calls that stretch a month-long period in which it accepts thousands of nominations. After that original end, Creative Loafing Tampa gave readers more time and moved the deadline to 11:59 p.m. on Sunday, June 14, 2026. At the close of that window, a tie in nominations would send both tied nominees into the voting round.
Could Tampa Bay readers pick more than once a day in the 2026 vote?
A reader could come back once a day and choose favorites in each of the nine categories, from Arts and Beauty & wellness through Services. The final round ran from July 23, 2026, until 11:59 p.m. on August 30, 2026, and readers could return once a day to pick across nine categories.
For any later edition, read the organizer's own announcement first: it is where the tie rule for nominations, the nomination dates and the voting dates appear together, and where a change to any of them would be stated.